Welcome to JP Melville's review, experience, and statement on foreign aid and the international development industry. A conservative faith in family. A love affair riding the riotous tensions between money, personal freedom, the majestic travesty of our specie's ecological footprint, and economic politics. Selected writing of both prose and poetry, anecdotal travel log to rhetorical essay, dating back from the 1980's to the present. Enjoy!

Monday 20 February 2012

Collected Notes #5 - Bio-economics

Will and Wishful Thinking

It is always surprising how many people think that the changes that have taken place in agriculture in the past generation or two are the natural effect of some immutable law of agricultural economics... There may indeed be imperatives that will determine the look of agriculture - but they will be the product of biological, not economic, law.  An economic system is only a way of organizing productive resources so that they accomplish economic purposes.   It is a function of custom, culture, and social values - but it is not above the laws of ecology.  We cannot have any kind of agriculture we want; our agriculture must conform to biological law.  But we can have the kind of agricultural economy we want.

Quote from :
Marty Strange -  The Economic Structure of a Sustainable Agriculture - 1985

Anything else to say, folks?  On with it now!

Collected Notes #4 - Self Discipline


Failed Commitments


We are confusing very unlike situations in our easy application of the `struggle for existence' to war.  The struggle is not now between individuals to decide the fitter; it is between vast bodies hurling death by wholesale.  We pick the physically fit and send them to the battleline; and there the fit are slain.  this is not the situation in nature... The final test in nature is adaptation... adaptation and adjustment mean peace, not war... The military method of civilization finds no justification in the biological struggle for existence.

The final conquest of man is of himself, and he shall be greater than when he takes a city.  The final conquest of society is of itself...

                                                                          Liberty Hyde Bailey. The Holy Earth. 1915



June 89                       
Arrival at my new job!  Woo Hoo!
Is the introduction of cash crops to a subsistence food production system as much a shock as withdrawing the opportunity for sales from a cash cropping system?
Boy, was I ever full of deep ideas.

July 89
Two mango trees planted right up against a stump that even in its state of decay stood taller than our jeep and stretched well over one metre in diameter.  Other charred stumps scattered over landscape.  Area recently cleared, in places soil underfoot still hot with smouldering roots.  Some dark colour in dirt - residual topsoil only.  Young, bright green cassava shoots, subsistence starch and export feed for European cattle.  A forest gone from incalculable diversity to two species of plants.  Awesome in the most horrific sense of the word.

August 89
How do I engage my new colleagues in development dialogue?
A recurring thought: if I had chosen to stay in Canada, I could have assumed an employment role that would have provided me with material resources well in excess of what my supervisor here might ever expect to access.  So what is his status based on?  A paltry, tiny pickup truck or patronage appointments to local government jobs?  Smug me who, on the basis of being able to purchase a suburban home one day, blithely deny that I could be corrupted.

September 89
Initiated the process of purchasing a motorcycle.
These people just can't think right.  Why don't they get their act together?  When it comes to the bullshit of materialism and environmental destruction and western influence I think I have a right to speak up.  I have convinced myself that owing a motorcycle is not a contradiction. Yip.

October 89
Do they have any ability to engage in objective research here?

November 89
What is this?  They've got information.  They have resources for field research.  Plenty of staff wishing they had more to do than hand copy old papers.  Why no research that I can see?  Why no ideas?  For example, one could just study increased soil biodiversity and any subsequent impact on grain production.  Nope.  Just fertilizer and hybrid seed trials in tiny plots on the edge of farmers’ fields.
Several farmers brought up the concern for the sale of their pararubber latex.  I said nothing but thought: can't eat it if you can't sell it.  Dispensable cogs in the international agricultural commodities markets, notorious for wildly fluctuating producer prices.
When I arrived in the village of Ban Nakham, a few nudges and winks from my colleagues indicated that I was to talk.  Some sort of speech?  I had not anticipated such a role.  I talked about world rice production, subsidies, and trade barriers for poor countries.  Blank faces.  Nudge, wink, whisper.  They want to know if you are married.  I am not married.  Smiles and laughter.
In Ban Nakham I met three women who had worked the underside of Bangkok, married foreigners, tasted the world, and under various circumstances returned to Ban Nakham without their husbands.  I wrote a letter for Kit to her husband in England - mostly to remind him to send money, without explicitly saying so.  Her two friends came over to visit while I wrote and we all smoked cigarettes and they invited me to stay and drink whisky and stay the night.  I declined but said I would come back and visit.  I didn’t.
Villages of many colours.

Collected Notes #3 - Helplessness


Goats and Sheep

Today, Sunday, I have just returned on my motorcycle to my room on the research station, 14 kilometres from the market and town.  I had bought a shirt, two blankets, coffee, and foodstuffs.  Bungua, my polite and friendly neighbour, comes over on his little motorscooter and beeps outside my door.  I welcome the break from scrubbing my laundry and go outside to see what he wants.  He has a message for me.  The Muslim fellow who buys and sells livestock - buffalo, cattle, sheep, and goats - had come around while I was gone to enquire about the order for the purchase of some goats.
What order?
The office for which I work does on-farm research.  My colleagues in this office are responsible for different kinds of government sponsored research programs - cash crops, large livestock, fish, and horticulture.  They collaborate with groups of farmers in assorted villages.  The projects are implemented by farmers and monitored by the researchers.  In theory, the research is a healthy blend of farmer participation and researcher expertise all-in-all intended to service the needs of the farmers.  In practice, it is a top-down injection of government policy which draws the rural population further into the national and international economies.  My original research parameters included cattle and buffalo only.
Frustrated with the obstacles that surrounded buffalo and cattle research in the Esan, I found myself yattering one day with Mr. and Mrs. Onsi about goats and sheep.  We sat in their straw covered shelter out in their rice paddy, taking a break from tending the buffalo and repairing the little fences which protected the young mango trees that had been planted in the rainy season.
"What can be done for research," I asked, drawing on my cigarette for a moment and exhaling. "You have no land to plant grass.  Where you already planted grass, it died.  Cattle and buffalo range from 3,000 to 10,000 baht per head.  Expensive to buy.  Expensive to feed.  You are already growing nitrogen fixing plants which can be fed as protein supplement.  I just don't know."
Mr. Onsi poured himself some water and drank long and thoughtfully.
"Don't know," he finally said.
Mrs. Onsi looked at me for a moment, smiling as always, and then turned her eyes' attention to the buffalo grazing on the bunds which surrounded each rice paddy.
I too looked at the beasts and after a silence said, "You know, in the Caribbean people keep goats on very limited plots of land - women are responsible mostly..."
So the idea of goats sprang to life.  Mr. Onsi was interested in the idea that he would not have to change much, if anything, in his husbandry practices, or on his farm in order to increase the numbers and kinds of animals which he kept.  Mrs. Onsi was interested in milk, how much a goat gave.  And, well, one thing leads to another.  I found out three weeks later that three families in Mr. and Mrs. Onsi's village were interested in goats.
That's one part of the job.  And that took six months to happen.  An idea.  A focus.  A potential project.
So I started dragging my co-workers all over Ubon province to find some goats.  Even had Padt check out Surin and Buriram Provinces, but no luck there.  There were leads and dead ends.  Classically, we found some under our feet, living not in the countryside but within the city of Ubon, grazing the streets.  Could urban goats adapt to country living?  A few weeks later more goats were found eighty kilometres away over by the border with Laos.  Their owner was the fellow who had stopped by this morning.  A Mr. Sombat.  Acquiring goats would not be a problem.
Getting my office interested would also be no problem.  Not only were they interested, they were energized.  A few were also already versed in goatology.  Muay was talking about food made with milk.  Padt had wanted to do goat research two or three years earlier, before he went off to do his master's degree.  Pochai, though a neophyte goatologist, began making plans to buy a few goats of his own, a sort of wedding present to himself and his fiancĂ©e.
Too energized, in fact.  I had only heard from Mr. Onsi that two other farmers in Khoo Khad were interested.  Never met them.  One for sure and two maybes?  Sure, I had discovered that goats existed in the region.  They were purportedly available but at what price?  In what condition?  There had been no visits by farmers to see goats firsthand.  There had been no meetings.  There were no plans.  This was the worst basis on which to begin a farmer based research trial.
What was this about an order for goats from Mr. Sombat down by Laos?
"Apparently," said Bungua my colleague, "while I was gone harvesting rice last Tuesday and Wednesday, a Mr. Sombat had stopped by the office and made some arrangements with my co-workers."
"What?" I exclaimed.
"That's what I know," Bungua said simply.
"It's out of my hands," I told Bungua.  "I mean, I suppose it's a good thing that it's out of my hands.  But for a moment there, it was so nice to think that I understood what was going on."
Bungua shrugged his shoulders and I shrugged mine.  Bungua drove off on his rattly scooter.  I look up into the trees at nothing and went back to my laundry.
There is only waiting to see what tomorrow brings.  Often enough, it all begins from there.

Collected Notes #2 - Cultural Recesses of Our Minds


Vague Notes from a Disorganized Desk

Canadian documents, scraps, letters:

The Executive Director’s memo to anyone who has local language words and English translation for dictionary project.  A lonely colleague’s scrawled missive expressing relief in having had a firm bowel movement.  A Canadian volunteer’s telegram, dismay at my publication of an idea, she writes, “How on earth could  you suggest that financial accounts are cultural?”

From my desk, I observe Thai real time theatre:

Pochai, a new arrival to the office, discretely distributes cash loans from desk to desk a week before paycheques.  Lisa, the girl in the market, comes to the office door with vegetables to sell to the foreigner (me), with a smile that belies the ardour in her eyes.  The women office workers turn their eyes to her, away, then to me moments later.  A United Nations World Food Programme electrolyte packet, intended for malnourished children, is pulled deftly from a desk drawer, torn at a corner with polished nails, and mixed into Nuanyung’s iced water.  Ah, the office meeting call: office boy clicking fingers, side jerk of head toward office manager’s closed door, a terse breathless calling of name: Patung!  Patung grates from his chair, sweat already breaking on his brow.

My brain: always wondering what motivates individuals, brain waves and synapses that ignite the cultural recesses of our minds.